Wandless Harry and his powers
lagattalucianese
katmac at katmac.cncdsl.com
Thu Jan 12 06:38:17 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 146293
>
...
>
> Also, JKR is really stretching the bounds of credulity by making
Harry
> appear to be a very ordinary wizard (even incapable of doing
> non-verbal spells, and useless at occlumency and leglimency), yet
one
> who is supposed to have been marked as an equal by Voldemort. It
does
> not add up, at the very least Harry should have some extra-ordinary
> skills that would make him stand out when compared to his peers. Yes
> ability to talk to snakes is in him, but he has no special skills
when
> it comes to combating dark magic or even for that matter
successfully
> overcoming the defenses of other dark wizards, so how is he supposed
> to fight the most powerful dark wizard of all?
>
...
>
> Harry
>
La Gatta Lucianese:
If you have just finished reading OotP, you surely remember Harry
himself expressing a similar opinion when Hermione and Ron press him
to teach the other students DADA, because he is the most qualified
person. Having lost the argument, he goes ahead and
trains "Dumbledore's Army", and does, IIRC, a pretty competent job of
it. So maybe he's more talented that either he or JKR lets on.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive