[HPforGrownups] Re: Who is she talking about?

[Bee Chase]

No: HPFGUIDX 146333


    greenfirespike quoted from a recent interview:

> >>>In the seventh and final Harry Potter book there will be deaths of 
> both goodies and baddies. She was talking to her husband, Neil, the 
> other day, after she had just written the death of one particular 
> character. "He shuddered. 'Oh, don't do that,' he said to me, but of 
> course I did." And with one swirl of her pen, millions of children 
> will weep or rejoice. "Neil is the only person I can talk to about 
> what happens because he instantly forgets," she says, laughing.<<<
> 
> Do we have a guess who this is? My guess is a 'goodie', and that 
> would be Neville.


SSSusan:
I think Neville's a good guess, greenfirespike, but I can certainly 
think of others which would cause Dr. Neil to shudder as well. Ron? 
Hermione? *One* of the twins? Molly or Arthur? Hagrid? Lupin (for 
us non-ESE!Lupiners)?

  Luckdragon:
  Oh, no! It can't possibly be Neville.
  For one thing it would just be too cruel to poor Alice Longbottom after the suffering she has already gone through to lose Neville whom it seems is the only one she interacts with in some small way. Also Neville has just begun to come out of his shell in the past couple of books. He is starting to show promise in becoming a person of character and a productive member of the herbologist community. Why kill him off after that. If LV goes after Neville I think Trevor will take the AK for him.
  The character I think will go for sure is Seamus. His mother has been such a doubting Thomas it would certainly turn her thinking around if it was revealed that her dear son's killer was LV and his goons. I bet the fighting Irish would come out in full force to support Harry after Seamus's demise.


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]