Squibs have genes to do magic?

Lia newbrigid at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 13 16:38:29 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146407


Jazmyn Concolor wrote:     
 

 >  
 >
 JK knows NOTHING about genetics.  You can not have 'mudbloods' if its a 
 dominant gene.  Its got to be a recessive gene if you can have two 
 muggles produce a wizard.  Genetics was my area in college, so I know 
 what I am talking about here. 
 <snip>
 JK's idea simply does not work.  If Wizard genes were always dominant, 
 there would be NO squibs born to purebred families.
 
Lia says:
   
 Aha!  I don't know as much as you do about genetics, but I'd always thought that something just didn't seem right.
 Perhaps, then, the magic gene is kind of...well, a "rogue", as it were?  Perhaps it isn't subject to the normal laws of genetics?
   
 Lia, who taught fourth grade science but certainly isn't an expert past that
   
 
  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive