Making a Horcrux

[Ceridwen]

No: HPFGUIDX 146414

Andie:
*(snip)*
> When Harry meets up with Voldy he will be defending himself and 
> whoever else is with him.  If he AK's him or finds another way to 
> kill him that is not murder that is self defense.  Therefore, his 
> soul should not be torn.  Which would mean that his soul would remain 
> whole and not be damaged.
> 
> Does anyone else see it this way?

Ceridwen:
Yes, I do.  Self defense is not murder, but it may stop a murder (of 
the person defending himself or herself).  In Harry's case, he is not 
only defending himself and others present, but the entire WW in the 
future.  Voldemort alive can only mean more innocent deaths until he is 
permanently gotten out of the way.  So, Harry killing Voldemort would 
be Harry preventing more murders and senseless killings.

Ceridwen.