Was Voldemort intentionally making HP a horcrux.

Amanda babyhrndz at yahoo.com
Sat Jan 14 01:57:19 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146437

>Richard:
> There's a hole in your argument where you have Voldemort under 
> an Unbreakable Vow not to harm Lily, in that it would have
> meant that in explicitly killing Lily (whom he gave the chance
> to step aside) would have invoked the Vow and thus death. <snip>
 
 
> "dobbyisdumbledore":
> I understand your position for reasons against Lily's death/a 
> Voldemort Unbreakable Vow.
> 
> However, that was rather secondary to the point regarding 
> intentionally making Harry a Horcrux before he tried to kill him.
>
Amanda:
In regards to making Harry a Horcrux, I think that is where Harry 
got the mark. In SS/PS, it states that,"A mark like that comes from 
being touched by an evil curse"..it doesn't say the AK, just 'a 
curse'. Later on we hear that the AK leaves no marks. IMO, LV went 
to make HP a horcrux, and when Lilly's sacrafice bounced that off, 
he tried the AK. The prophesy states that "he will mark him as an 
equal". LV marked HP as he was making him an equal w/ the horcrux. 
When it didn't work, he got mad and did the AK, which bounced back 
again because of the sacrifice of Lilly. Again, all IMO.
~Amanda










More information about the HPforGrownups archive