CHAPDISC: HBP8, Snape Victorious

[lagattalucianese]

No: HPFGUIDX 146606

> 
> SSSusan:
> These are fascinating questions.  I'd never thought about the 
> possibility that Tonks losing her metamorphmagus ability might 
*make* 
> her less clumsy and awkward.  But -- okay, confession time -- as I 
> read, I did wonder whether this was indeed Tonks.  In fact, this 
lack 
> of clumsiness and her gloominess and her changed patronus all made 
me 
> think... even though I was *never* in SAD DENIAL... that Tonks was 
> somehow actually Sirius!  (Okay, throw rotten tomatoes at me, I can 
> take it -- it was just a thought that flitted into my mind as I read 
> this. :-)) 
> 
La Gatta Lucianese:

And in HBP.26, when Dumbledore slides from the rock "with the sudden 
agility of a much younger man" and sets out for shore "with a perfect 
breast stroke", that's Sirius too? Oh, I like it! (Only, why wasn't he 
doing the dog paddle?) ;D

Does that mean that it was really Sirius that Snape killed?