DD, Snape, Phoenix etc.

[wingedheels]

No: HPFGUIDX 146722

I'm Delurking. I did study the archives and hopefully I am not 
repeating forgone conclusions, BUT:

IMO Snape has become the most interesting character in Harry's 
life. I believe that he is still WITH DD.As some have written, no 
way would DD plead for his life. So was Snape really killing DD, 
or could DD have been someone or something else at the time 
of Snape's curse? Wormtail maybe? 

I wonder this because in the beginning DD tells Harry that it 
wouldn't be impossible for him to be impersonated "DD said" my 
favorite jam is raspberry."
or: it was DD and he was making Snape complete the plan. (As 
HP had to in the cave.)

The Phoenix is interesting too, as some have written HP thought 
he saw it sailing in the blue sky at DD's funeral...interesting that 
Phoenixes are regenerated through fire. 

But my one nagging question is: Can one person make several 
Unbreakable Vows in a lifetime? Because, couldn't it just be 
possible that that is why DD trusts Snape so fully? They made 
an unbreakable vow some years ago?  

And if this is so, and the DD/SS plan theory is true then He didn't 
want to kill DD, but DD begged him because he was going to die 
anyway and if Snape didn't kill him Snape himself would die? 
(remember in Hogsmead when he told HP that only Snape 
would do?)

also:

Ceridwen said:
> <snip> And now, neither Snape nor Draco are useful. LV might
> keep them around for window dressing, but they lost their
> usefulness the minute they had to leave Hogwarts. IMO, if
> they go back to LV, they're treading on thin ice. <snip>

Explains Snape's reaction to HP's taunts of Cowardice...

Thanks for letting me chime in!!
Wingedheels