Wands & Wizards (was: Book 1 Questions)

gwen_of_the_oaks GAP5685 at AOL.com
Thu Jan 19 21:27:31 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146724


Sherry asked:
> > 
> > > 2.   The Malfoy's are suppose to be "upper crust" in the WW and,
> > > according to Draco,"...mother's up the street looking at wands,"
> > > (Ch. 5, Pg 77).  Mr. Ollivander states, The wand chooses the 
> > > wizard." (Ch. 5, Pg 85).  Is Mrs. Malfoy buying Draco's wand 
while he's being fitted for robes?  Would a wand that did not choose 
the wizard be good enough for the Malfoy's son, considering their
standing in the WW?
> > 
Now Gwen:

I always considered the "wand chooses the wizard" as important in 
certian situations, but not a practical necessity.  A good parallel 
would be a muggle buying a musical instrument like violin:  A 
virtuoso, or dedicated, talented musician would need to pick their 
own, hold each one, assess the quality of sound that each made, etc.  
Someone just learning or taking lessons for kicks could use a second-
hand instrument or one that had been in the family, and it would not 
hinder their ability to learn or play.


And so, in the wizarding world, there are many with average 
abilities, and no world-saving destiny, who do not have the need for 
a super-sensitive, high-performance wand.  The Malfoys could be 
buying a wand based solely on looks or price.  You know, "The most 
expensive dragon heartstring you have, please.  At least 14 inches, 
and preferably a dark wood."



Gwen










More information about the HPforGrownups archive