Draco
juli17 at aol.com
juli17 at aol.com
Sat Jan 21 19:54:24 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 146811
Quick_Silver wrote:
There seems to be a view in fandom that Draco is somehow
in really big trouble with Voldemort and that his life is going to
be in danger. Everyone, including Draco's own mother, didn't think
that he'd be able to complete his task yet Draco basically did
complete it. He got a group of Death Eaters into Hogwarts and
managed to get Dumbledore at the mercy of his wand. These are hardly
insufficient tasks that Draco completed in the service of the Dark
side. Voldemort may have wanted Draco to fail so that he could
punish Lucius but instead Draco did something even better...he
eliminated Dumbledore (or caused the situation that led to
Dumbledore's death). Even the loss of Snape as a spy isn't that big
deal...it not like we've really seen or heard Snape do anything for
the Dark side (until the situation that Draco brought about forced
him to kill Dumbledore). What's more Snape was at Hogwarts to spy on
Dumbledore so if Draco had killed Dumbledore Snape would still be
useless.
I could be completely wrong and Draco could be in huge trouble from
Voldemort but IMO there's just as likely a chance that we'll see
Voldemort pinning medals on Draco's and Snape's chests in book 7 for
a job while done.
Julie:
I also don't see Snape and Draco hiding out in Book 7. If we
assume DDM!Snape, then part of the reason Dumbledore gave
Snape the DADA position was that he knew it would be Snape's
last year at Hogwarts--i.e., it was time for Snape to
solidify his position with Voldemort and the DEs. If that
was the case, then it would make no sense for Snape to
be on the run. The whole point was to get him closer to
Voldemort. Since Voldemort expected Snape to complete the
task for Draco (per Snape) then Voldy shouldn't hold it
against Snape.
It is possible Snape will put Draco in hiding, should
Draco's life be in danger for not completing the task,
but again Voldemort expected this, and probably will feel
he can still make use of Draco. If Draco is punished, it
probably won't be by his death, but by being Crucioed for
a while, or some punishment to one of his parents.
What I'm eager to find out is how Snape will help Draco stay
alive while not getting sucked into true DE activities, while
maintaining his *own* cover. And if he will share his real
goals with Draco (i.e. make Draco a DDM man also). Can he or
will he trust Draco that far? And would Draco be willng to
switch sides if it means going against his father?
Both Snape and Draco have hard choices to make, and no doubt
a price to pay if and when they choose what's right over
what's easy. Poor Snape! Poor Draco!
Julie
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive