ESE!Lupin condensed

[festuco]

No: HPFGUIDX 146856

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Jen Reese" <stevejjen at e...> wrote:

> I'm sure there are other events I'm not remembering. No offense to 
> Pippin here because ESE!Lupin is probably the most well-thought out 
> and clever theory around, but I'm hoping for something even bigger 
> as the huge denoument of the series. 

When I first came to this list I participated in a few ESELuppin!
debates. Nowadays I stay out of them, because I think this theory is
so far fetched and so based on wishful reading of canon that it is -
sorry Pippin - a waste of time to discuss it. I always wondered why
somebody would want to make such a weird and unlikely theory and when
Pippin explained she thougth the books were on the murder of Sirius
Black I knew this theory was utter rubbish. Sorry for the strong
language Pippin, I very, very much enjoy your other posts but
ESELupin! No. Not in the last place because I very much get the
impression you want to twist and twirl all kinds of facts so that they
fit into your theory, instead of looking at your theory and see if it
fits the facts. The books are about one Harry Potter and the murder of
Sirius Black though very important to Harry is just not that important
to the plot. These books are not murder mysteries. They are the
journey of Harry Potter to adulthood and to the defeat of Voldemort. 

Gerry