VA/H=Mx13+RP? (was: Was the eavesdropper unimportant to Harry?)

[juli17ptf]

No: HPFGUIDX 147066

Carol 
> wrote:
>  And yet, setting aside the death of Dumbledore (which has yet to
> > be fully explained), Wormtail's sins against Harry are much 
greater
> > than Snape's. 
> > 

Lupinlore wrote:
> Well, that is setting aside a lot.  But I disagree that even a DDM!
> Snape has sinned less against Harry than has Wormtail.  He was at 
> least as responsible for the Potter's deaths as Peter was.  And his 
> methodical abuse of Harry over six years is reprehensible beyond 
> belief, at least equal to Peter's other sins.
> 

Julie:
Assuming DDM!Snape (as you are above) are you saying you think
telling Voldemort about the prophecy then REGRETTING it and making
a SINCERE effort to atone for that mistake by trying to keep the
intended victims alive (going to DD, switching sides, etc) is 
equal to deliberately betraying two of your closest friends to
an almost certain death?

As for Snape's methodical verbal/emotional abuse of Harry, again
are you saying that his abuse of Harry is EQUAL to Peter's murder
of Cedric, murder of 12 other innocent people and very willing
resurrection of a psychopath? VA/H=Mx13+RP? (Where VA=verbal abuse,
H=Harry, M=murder, RP=resurrected psychopath). 

Maybe you actually believe they are equal but I don't. 

Julie