Plan for events on the Tower (was Re: Do any list members think Dumbledore might have asked Snape to kill him?)

[Maria Vaerewijck]

No: HPFGUIDX 147133

Julie:
  
>> So I agree that there was no plan for the specific events on 
the Tower, just a contigency agreement about who would live or 
die if the worst possible thing came to pass. Which it did. <<


maria8162001:
I don't think there was no plan about the events in the tower. I 
think we are forgetting or overlooking one or 2 important things. 
The reason, I believe that everything that happen on the tower was 
all planned, is first, it was on that evening that DD chose to 
asked Harry to accompany him to look for the horcrux. And I believe 
both DD and Snape know something's going to happen that evening 
(Draco letting the DEs in) and they know where it's going to 
happen. Second, if it wasn't planned, why did Snape stun or attack  Prof. Flitwick when he came to fetch Snape to help fight the death 
eaters? And how did he know directly that DD, Draco and some DEs 
were on the tower? Why did DD chose to land on the tower, when they 
could have landed anywhere inside Hogwarts and use the front door 
to go inside the castle? That would be more safe both for him and 
Harry to use the front door as it was far from the figthing.

But the things that stays with me and in my opinion it is important 
as the readers doesn't pay much attention to these, and I cannot 
get them out of my mind are the first 2 questions. Why did Snape 
attack Prof. Flitwick if there was no plan and if he really doesn't 
know that the moment has come(the plan)? And how did he know that 
DD and Draco and perhaps other DEs are on the tower? Any idea? I 
really would love to hear some ideas about these questions, which 
have been nagging me. I don't like Snape since from the first book 
but I don't think he's that evil. I guess, there's more something 
about that events on the tower. I've also read Mr. Rickman's (Snape) 
interview and he said also that there is more to Snape than what 
you see or how he look, something like that.
  
 
  maria8162001