Draco and Harry
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sat Jan 28 20:49:06 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 147195
Geoff:
< HUGE SNIP>
> This leads me on to the main thrust of my argument. Many group
> members seem to be dropping into a pattern of describing our two
> protagonists as Harry "best thing since sliced bread" Potter and
> Draco "puer horribilis" Malfoy.
<SNIP>
Alla:
Too funny, but I think I should clarify my position on this point.
Do I think that Harry is a better person than Draco? Absolutely, I
do. But the thing is, I don't really think that it takes a lot for
any character to be a better person than Draco, SO if I say that
Harry is a better person than Draco, it really does not make Harry A
PERFECT person in my eyes, far from it. I mean, if I were to say
that Harry is a person of better moral character than .... I don't
know....Dumbledore, than yeah it would bring Harry close to
sainthood. Right now, in my eyes, Harry is a good person, but has
plenty of flaws. It is just in my book Draco's flaws are much WORSE
than Harry's. That's all. MANY characters are in my book much, much
better "people" than Draco. I would not dream of saying that they
are perfect. It does not take a lot, IMO, to be a better person than
Draco, really. As long as the character does not wish to torture and
kill Muggleborns, they are better people than Draco.
Geoff:
<SNIP>
So I would agree with those who feel
> that there might be some sort of rapprochement between our
> two "friends";' probably not the back-slapping familiarity which
we
> see between Ron and Harry but certainly a lessening of the
acrimony
> and a move towards cooperation in order that both of them might
keep
> themselves and indirectly the Wizarding World - intact.
>
Alla:
Absolutely, after HBP I see it as a possibility, not a definite
possibility, but a possibility nevertheless. What I do NOT see and I
can be wrong of course is Draco and Harry becoming bestest friends
as Betsy argued ( I think, sorry if I misunderstood). There is a
HUGE difference IMO between tolerating each other for common goal
and becoming friends.
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive