special treatment of Malfoy

[fuzz876i]

No: HPFGUIDX 147275

> Fuzz876i
>  There were two people that would actually dare
> > to punish Malfoy and one of them was not actually who he said he 
was
> > and the other is Professor Mcgonagell.
> 
> Magpie:  What's even more extreme is 
> Snape's *unfair* treatment of Harry, whom he personally dislikes 
more than 
> any other student.  
> 
> Other teachers treat Malfoy like any other student.  McGonagall, 
Fake!Moody, 
> Hagrid and Filch are all shown treating him like a student in need 
of 
> discipline.
> 
> 

Yes that may seem like it would be the case but
Snape's hatred of 
Harry is a carry over from Snape's school days with
James Harry's 
father. Is it right to just discipline Harry and Ron
in this case 
or should all involved received detention? I am not
saying that it 
is wrong for other professors to treat Malfoy as a
student and 
discipline him when it is needed. What I am saying is
this the 
punishment should be fair and precise and not based on
what one 
student says as it was in this case. Malfoy said that
Harry tried 
to curse him when the truth was that they had actually
tried to 
curse each other at the same time. When Harry and Ron
tried to 
explain this to Snape they both received detention and
Malfoy got 
nothing. In The Prisoner of Azkaban Malfoy walked into
class late 
after going to the hospital wing and being treated for
the wound 
from Buckbeak and all Snape said at that time was to
settle down if 
that had been Harry or Ron it would have been
detention or 50 points 
a piece from Gryfendor. Is it really fair to show
this much 
favoritism to one student? In my opinion I think not
if you punish 
one all should be punished as it would seem in this
case.

Fuzz876i