back to Blacks was Re: Snape and DD

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 147292


> La Gatta Lucianese:
> 
> Gesundheit.

Potioncat:
Thank you.

> La Gatta Lucianese:
> Canon, please? I  just checked out Mr. and Mrs. Potter in the HPL, 
> and nowhere does it say boo about Mrs. Potter's maiden name. Or Mr. 
> Potter's first name.

Potioncat:
My mistake. I thought you were referring to Dorea Black as Harry's 
grandmother.

I agree the age doesn't fit. At least "I" don't consider 57 to be 
elderly!!!!! My teenagers do, of course, but I wouldn't have expected 
it of JKR.

Now that we've had time to discuss the chart a bit, it doesn't look 
as if the Potters and Longbottoms on the chart are  Harry's or 
Neville's grandparents. Of course, the interesting thing might be, 
what happened to James's cousin? (the one son of Dorea and Charlus)


I'll still put my wizarding fortune on a Sirius-Severus connection 
rather than a James-Severus connection. James seems to have overcome 
his feeling about Severus, but Sirius never did.