Some Questions on Book 6

dd_ur_great dd_ur_great at yahoo.co.uk
Tue Jan 31 13:06:25 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 147357

> ed9743621:
> >   1. Dumbledore is really dead or would be returning back in 
> > the last Book (I hope so)?
> >   2. Was the killing of Dumbledore by Snape a deliberate one 
> > or is just a front to continue his spying duty on Voldemort?
> 
> Geoff:
> Pick up from message 132907 and skip through the list from there 
> onwards. I think you'll find a fair bit to keep you occupied....

dd_ur_great:
Hi Ed, I'm new like you to this group, and I have some pretty basic 
(compared to the other intellectuals on this site, haha!!) questions 
too... I think that there's no getting away from the fact that Snape 
did really perform AK on DD and so DD is really dead (yes, I do 
really HATE to even think about that!!). But in the wizarding world 
that doesn't mean he won't come back in some form to help Harry, I 
think he will, maybe through his portrait?

But I think Snape may not be all bad, the murder of DD may be in fact 
masterminded by DD himself, there have been some interesting posts 
here including ideas even going as far as assisted suicide!! And 
yes, thanks a lot, Geoff, for that enlightening rejoinder!!










More information about the HPforGrownups archive