[HPforGrownups] If Regulus lives ... Re: The Veil and The Mirror

[MadameSSnape at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 154730

 
In a message dated 7/1/2006 8:35:41 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,  
littlehorn489 at hotmail.com writes:

We  know that Sirius and James communicated via a pair of mirrors, but
we don't  know for sure that the mirror in Harry's possession is one of
that pair-  presumably James' was in Godric's Hollow or on his person
when he died,  which would be difficult for Sirius to obtain. If
Regulus also had a  mirror, which he left on his death (or 'death') in
Grimmauld Place Sirius  could pair it up with his own- perhaps stored
in his bank vault, or perhaps  they were two seperate pairs.

It would, perhaps, explain why Sirius  never tried to use it, or didn't
mention it in the fireplace after  Christmas, if he knew saying 'James
Potter' didn't  work.


-------------------------
Sherrie here:
 
IMHO, the simplest explanation is that Harry's mirror is a new one - Sirius  
enchanted it fresh for him, & attuned it to his.  
 
Sherrie
(sorry for the short post - it's late, & the race just got  over)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]