Dr Neil shuddered for ONE of them (Was: Who dies?)

[allies426]

No: HPFGUIDX 154937

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Hagrid" <aussie_lol at ...> 
wrote:
>>>>>
Aussie:
R: Well, yes, let's be honest: that would be stupid. But you did
tell him which ones were up for the chop. Apparently he shuddered
and said, "Oh no, not that one."

JK: He did on one of them, yeah."

That bit of the interview seems that if Dr Neil reacted strongly to
one of the two that die, they are not a pair like Fred and George
(or why would he hear "Fred and George" -and recact like "NO!, not
George, anyone but George - Fred is ok, but Not George!")

They could be separate killings and non-connected.

Who does Dr Neil like in the characters?

I am reluctant to say it, but I think Ron's death would have the
greatest effect at bringing others together to fight.>>>>>>>

Allie:

I think maybe Dr. Neil would shudder if any of the kids died.  Thus 
far, the only student we lost was Cedric, and we barely knew him.  I 
think any of Harry's friends would cause a shudder.  I *cannot* 
believe she would kill off Ron, although I agree it would unite 
everyone.  That would be THE WORST death of the series, I think, 
even worse than if she killed Harry.