Harry Horcrux redux :)

Emily imamommy at sbcglobal.net
Fri Jul 7 02:58:49 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 155013

Alla:
> Heeee, it seems like we did not talk about Harry horcrux recently :)
snip

imamommy:
Thanks for bringing it up!  I've been trying to wrestle with this one 
lately.  I still bank on Harry being a horcrux; I read the essay you 
referenced, and I'm not convinced Ms. Bostelmann is interpreting the 
info correctly.  I also found this on Mugglenet:
http://www.mugglenet.com/editorials/thenorthtower/nt44.shtml

It contributes some other ideas to the discussion, including the 
thought of an accidental horcrux.  It seems to me that forming a 
horcrux would need to be pretty intentional; it's highly advanced dark 
magic.

I still hold the H!H theory because of the mind link.  Also (about to 
beat dead thestral) I still think Harry may survive a dementors kiss 
by somehow releasing that piece of Voldemort's soul instead of his own.

What I've really been struggling with is why LV would want a human 
horcrux, and why he would try to kill Harry if he made him one.  Could 
he have perhaps hoped to somehow have an Inferius!Horcrux!Baby Harry?  
(EWWWWWW!)  LV was definitely pushing the limits, but what exactly did 
he hope to accomplish?

imamommy
who needs to go back and poke through the archives







More information about the HPforGrownups archive