IHHS, the I Hate Horcruxes Society (was Re: Harry Horcrux redux)

[esmith222002]

No: HPFGUIDX 155158


> >
> 
> Alla:
> 
> Oh, I am sorry, Brothergib.
> 
> You won't be angry at me for disagreeing with you after you agreed 
> with me , I hope. :)

Don't worry Alla - I am used to us not being in agreement!!
> 
> It is Harry's quest, not Snape. :) I don't think Snape will be 
chief Horcruxes destroyer, sorry.
> 
> What I was trying to say that Horcruxes will be important for the 
> plot, not that it will be impossible for Harry to deal with them.
> 

Okay, lets consider this;
Diary Horcrux - Destroyed
Ring Horcrux - Destroyed
Locket Horcrux - we think we know where it is, so isn't a major 
obstacle
Nagini Horcrux - as said before, will probably be dealt with in the 
final confrontation
Hufflepuff Horcrux - no idea where it is or how well protected
Final Horcrux - No idea where it is, what it is or how well protected.

It is clear that DD could not find or even be sure of the final two 
Horcruxes. DD also struggled to deal with the ring Horcrux and even 
get near the locket Horcrux. So are we supposed to believe that Harry 
has the ability to a) locate and b) destroy these Horcruxes. No he 
does not. What Harry possesses is the ability to destroy Voldemort 
once the Horcruxes are destroyed!!It is Snape (who knows more about 
the Dark Arts than anyone) who is ideally placed to destroy the two 
unknown Horcruxes. As I've said before, Harry will face LV thinking 
that certain Horcruxes are still in place - leading to immense over 
confidence on the part of LV.

As always, just my opinion.

Brothergib