Voldemorts Wand - It may not matter

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 155417

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, James Sharman <jamess at ...> wrote:
>
> It seems that some people think there is some kind critical 
information at
> stake with regard to how Voldemorts wand was returned to him.
 I think it's irrelevant. Think of the conversations between V and 
Wormtail.


*snip*

Doddie here:

I don't think's it's "critical"....but anyone would have to admit that 
if either snape nor wormtail were at Godrics hollow........it could 
have a major impact on the plot line...(makes me also wonder where 
hagrid was to be transporting infant harry around and get Sirius's 
motorcycle....so soon after the potter deaths..In all likelyhood; 
Hagrid would be the biggest culprit to inadvertanly place voldy's wand 
into one of Voldy's follower's hands...hence I began to wonder about 
snape...I don't think Hagrid would give something away to anyone other 
than 1. DD or 2. Someone DD would trust....
  Hence, this is why I think Hagrid may well of given said wand to 
Snape....and we all know that Hargrid would have been swept away by 
details of rescuing baby Harry...he would have been too distracted by 
Harry.(he takes his "saving lives" protocl very seriously. 

So I agree with you that it may not matter on the "WHOLE"....but I 
think it's a massive clue..  I love this clue not only because this 
could have happened in Godricks Hollow...but this may also may have 
happened in POA....in the shrieking shack scene....(a great place that 
wormtail may have hidden said wand throughout said school year or 
before or after--irregardless it was a place that snape had access 
to)...

I would explain why snape was all on about the "confundus 
charm"....seeing as he would love nothing better than to see the trio 
expelled from Hogwarts for casting spells against him!!!

This adds yet another light when considering snape...

Doddiemoemoe
(who thinks we will all be surprised when we find out who was/was not 
ther and also to knew that something "huge" was to happen there..
(wouldn't it be great if aberforth was hiding in a wardrobe 
somewhere?!?!?!)