Question to Neri and other supporters of Harry as horcrux
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 15 14:44:04 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 155422
Okay, here it goes. As I mentioned earlier, I am sitting on the
fence as to whether Harry is a horcrux or not, I think in
metathinking terms being a horcrux is a very easy reason for Harry
to be ready to sacrifice himself, and even if he is not one, I still
think that he would believe at some point that he is.
Now, as always with Neri's posts, I find his arguments to be very
very convincing and absolutely buying the mechanics of
how ""Accidental Horcrux" can be created.
So, please, please you don't have to convince me of the possibility,
I do buy it.
What I have not seen anybody addressing though yet and if I missed
it, please refer me to the relevant post? :)
That is Rebecca's reference to Dumbledore's remark that Harry's soul
is "untarnished and whole".
So, to anybody who thinks that Harry is a Horcrux, what is your
interpretation of Dumbledore's remark, especially since JKR said
that Dumbledore's guesses are never far off mark ( paraphrase), I
think specifically in relation to horcruxes?
Do you think Dumbledore is lying here? Do you think he does not know?
Do you think that Harry's soul somehow could be "untarnished and
whole" with the piece of Voldy sould attached to it? ( I confess I
find this interpretation to be highly unlikely)
Thank you very much,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive