Harry's Soul with Harry as horcrux

[triinum]

No: HPFGUIDX 155461

> Alla:
> 
> Okay, yes, this **is** my question and I am still not quite clear. 
> What does Dumbledore assume when he makes this remark?
> 
> Is it your argument that when Dumbledore says that Harry's soul 
> is "untarnished and whole" , what he **really** means to say is 
> that "Harry's soul is untarnished and whole, **except** that piece 
> of Voldie that we don't count"?

Triin:

He could mean that when all other horcruxes (and V's body) are gone
and it comes down to who gets to use *Harry's* body - Harry soul or V
soul fragment - then Harry's soul wins because its untarnished and
whole, while the V soul fragment is only a piece. 
Just an idle thought.

T