What really happened on the tower.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 155469

"whtwitch91" <whtwitch91 at ...> wrote:

> And he was to take the fake locket 
> horcrux with him. "See, Master, I was
> able to take this from DD. Of course, 
> I killed him for you as well." That way
> Voldemort would know someone was on to
> his horcruxes and he would immediately
> start to check up on them.

If the good guys wanted Voldemort to know that they knew all about his
Horcruxes (and that would be the last thing on planet Earth they'd
want to do) all they'd have to do is send Voldemort a little note
telling him about the one Harry had already destroyed and another one
that Dumbledore had taken care of.

> I predict that DD will show up about 
> the halfway point or earlier. 

I predicted right after book 4 came out that Dumbledore would die at
the end of book 6, and not a comic book death (see lord of the rings)
where the wizard dies and then somehow comes back, Dumbledore will
really and permanently be dead. For artistic reasons JKR had to do it,
when Harry and Voldemort have their apocalyptic fight in book 7 he
must do so alone. 

> here is my theory. See what you think. 

Your theory doesn't explain some things. If Snape is really a good guy
how could he be so brain dead dumb as to make that unbreakable vow? 
Snape was already the most trusted adviser Voldemort had, so how did
him murdering the most powerful wizard the good guys had help the good
guys? And there's something wlse not often commented on:

In chapter 2 Snape said he helped provide information that caused the
death of Sirius Black. If that wasn't true why did he say it? How did
he expect to get away with a lie of that magnitude to the two people
who know more about the incident than anyone else on planet Earth?
Kreature went to Narcissa and told her secret stuff about Sirius, and
Bellatrix was the one who actually killed him. Snape would be a
absolute fool to say that if it wasn't true. Those two knew the truth
and if they thought Snape's boast was full of hot air one or both
would have said something, but they did not.

Eggplant