[HPforGrownups] Does the Foe Glass Prove Snape = DD's Man?

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 155685

Angie wrote:

> I just had a thought about Snape and the Foe Glass in GOF...
>
> I'm assuming the Foe Glass showed Barty Crouch's (the son's) foes and
> not the Real Mad Eye Moody because I can't imagine RealMoody's foes
> would ever include Dumbledore.
>
> Based on that assumption, does the fact that the Foe Glass showed Snape
> as a Foe of one of Voldemort's faithful and true Death Eaters at least
> provide support for the proposition that Snape is DD's man?
>
> If Snape was a true follower of Voldemort, why would the Foe Glass show
> him as a foe of a Death Eater?
>
> (In a way, it seems the Foe Glass is the obverse of the Mirror of
> Erised -- it shows what we desperately do NOT desire -- our foes
> closing in on us.)
>


Kemper now:
Crouch Jr views Snape as a foe.
I'm sure he knows that Snape was released from any wrong doing based
on Dumbledore's word.  Even Voldemort thinks Snape is a foe throughout
(until Snape returns to him after the TWT), so if Crouch Jr and
Voldemort chit chatted about the old times and Snape's name came up,
I'm sure it wasn't in a good light.
Thus, Snape is a foe.

If Voldemort was coming up on Moody!CrouchJr, I wonder what the Foe
Mirror would show.  Does the Foe Mirror show one's true foes or his
perceived foes?

Kemper, who believes Snape is a true foe of Voldemort