Does the Foe Glass Prove Snape = DD's Man?.

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 155712

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "eggplant107" <eggplant107 at ...> 
wrote:
>
> "gelite67" gelite67@ wrote:
> 
> > does the fact that the Foe Glass showed Snape
> > as a Foe of one of Voldemort's faithful and 
> > true Death Eaters at least  provide support
> > for the proposition that Snape is DD's man? 
> 
>Eggplant wrote:
> No. In the first place Harry says in book 5 that you shouldn't trust
> things like the Foe Glass too much because they can be fooled. In 
the
> second place being a foe of Voldemort does not prove you are one of
> the good guys, not by a long shot. And I must say the fact that 
Snape
> murders Dumbledore does not particularly strengthen the theory that
> Snape is Dumbledore's friend. 
> 


And boy, Harry's been right about everything up to now, hasn't he?  I 
think the Foe Glass shows you who you perceive to be your enemy, not 
that they really are.

And again, in your opinion, it was "murder".  I still believe DD's 
death was for the greater good - which is to save Harry's life so 
Harry can totally defeat Voldemort and also, not to blow Snape's 
cover and to install Snape into LV's lair until the defeat of LV.  I 
believe it is something that Snape hated to have to do, that he 
argued with DD about this task, but DD made him swear to do whatever 
he(DD) asked Snape to do - just like Dumbledore made Harry swear 
before entering the cave.

The similarity between Snape & Harry's loyalty to Dumbledore are 
amazing.

colebiancardi(who doesn't think Snape, DD or Harry are stupid or 
dumb.  Things are not as they seem - and that IS real life)