Lily's protection VS DD's Protection

Emilynne srhchttrsn at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 21 18:45:02 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 155775

divya_thomas1 wrote:
> Would Snape suffer the same consequences as that of LV and if he
> has a horcrux placed then the whole story will be sort of repeated
> again.  So the point arises whether the book will conclude or leave
> as one of those Robin Cook books which leave the conclusion for the
> reader to decide....................................................



The same thing won't happen to Snape because as far as we know he
isn't involved in the whole business of splitting  his soul. We've
seen others perform AV (like in GoF) and their soul didn't split.

I think we would have had some inclination at this point if SS was
involved with Horcruxes in any way.

Emilynne











More information about the HPforGrownups archive