[HPforGrownups] Re: What really happened on the tower.

[MadameSSnape at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 155815

 
In a message dated 7/22/2006 2:07:58 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time,  
aceworker at yahoo.com writes:

DA  Jones Here:

Odd Idea. Let me see if it has wings. The first PT and the  second if they 
were fired by someone would most likely have to be by someone  with an 
invisibility cloak. The only other one in canon is the one Mad Eye  Moody owns. Where 
was Mad Eye during this book? He certainly seems to have  disapeared. Perhaps 
it was Mad Eye who saved Harry?

Was Mad Eye on top  of th tower perhaps as DD witness to Snape's actions so 
Snape could be cleared  latter? 


 
---------------------------------
Sherrie here:
 
If Mad-Eye (or Neville, who I've also seen nominated) was on top of the  
tower at that point, I'd run a check of their left arms.  There was a  barrier 
there - the only people who could get through it were those who wore the  Dark 
Mark.  That leaves us with Severus, The Big Blonde Dude, or a random  spell that 
missed its true mark and just HAPPENED to hit Greyback at the right  moment.  
No, I don't think it was Harry, either vrbl or nvbl - either way,  he'd have 
had to move his wand, which the narrator tells us he was unable to do  at that 
point.
 
Sherrie


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]