Arthur right or not? ( was Hate crimes (was Re: muggle baiting v

[Jordan Abel]

No: HPFGUIDX 155906

> Julie:
> Oh, and regarding the specific ton-tongue taffy incident, Arthur is
> also a Weasley, thus a good person.

Doesn't follow at all, witness Percy.

> Julie:
> In that scene, I ask again, was
> he right or wrong to chastise Fred and George for misusing magic
> on a Muggle? Was he being a conscientious father trying to instill  a
> strong moral code in his sons, or is he just a  boring old fuddy duddy
> who can't see a good, clean joke when it's in front of his face?
>
> Julie, who thinks Arthur is one of the "goodest" of the good guys

Regardless of how "good" he is w.r.t. opposing the side of evil, he's
in his own way more anti-muggle than anyone else I've seen in the
books.

-- 
Random832