Barty Jr's motivation.....
Hagrid
aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Tue Jul 25 16:20:06 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 155970
> "sugaranddixie1" wrote:
> >
> > ...in teaching Harry's class about the unforgivable curses?
> > The only conclusion I can come to is that he thought that was
> > what the "real" Moody would do & so did it to make his
> > masquerade more convincing.Maybe he never heard the
> > saying , "Forewarned is forearmed". Did Voldmort order Barty Jr.
> > to show Harry the curses so he (Barty Jr.) could report back to LV
> > with Harry's reactions? Did he think Harry's advance knowledge
> > would somehow cause him to freeze up with fear when the showdown
> > took place? Any thoughts?
>
> Pippin:
> Even if Harry only believed he had successfully resisted imperius,
> before, he might still have done it 'again', as with the patronus
> spell.
aussie:
Three reasons I can think of:
- It had been some time since Barty got the chance to have a wand in
his hand. Apart from the imperius on his dad, Barty hasn't been able
to use any unforgiveables since entering Azkaban. Now where better
than a Dark Arts class.
- Tom wanted to teach Dark Arts himself. Any dark wizard getting into
that role would want to include Unforgiveables to the curriculum. Once
LV takes over, Hogwarts would get a very different teaching mentality.
("Class, put your Horcrux text books away. Parsel tongue lessons
starting now.")
- Another thing a dark wizard would want, is to look out for new
recruits. Who shows a natural talent for Unforgivables? Who has a
higher tollerance of pain? Who can torture a spider and not feel
remorse?
The twins saw it in their class too. I don't think Barty Jr was
teaching Unforgivables exclusively to Harry's class.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive