[HPforGrownups] Harry's fate - Best of Both

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 156022

> bboyminn:
>  ...
> Though, I could live much better with Harry both dying and living. I
> have predicted various scenarios for this happening in the past, but
> lately I have been leaning toward a trip behind The Veil, and a
> return. I won't go into details since I've posted on this several
> times. But The Veil and general mythology seem to lean in this
> direction. Harry wouldn't be the first person to go behind The Veil
> and return while on a Hero's Quest.
> ...
>  

Kemper now:
I don't mind the idea of using the Veil, but have a sense of
disappointment if it were used in the Final Battle sequense as we've
already had a battle in the Dept of Mysteries.

The Veil used somewhere in the middle at the DoM would be ok.  Or if
The Veil was stolen (Voldemort tries to coax some of his soul pieces
back to the land of the living) and taken somewhere else would be ok,
too.

But part of the excitement of most of the climatic battles is the new scenery.
The obstacles for the Stone
The Chamber
The Shack/The Lake (two because of time turner)
The Graveyard
The DoM (yes we've seen the Lobby, but most of that battle is twix DD and LV)
Hogwarts (ok, not really)

To go back a couple of books would feel... blah.  I'm hoping for some
place new.

So what are your thoughts on the where and when?

Kemper