Snape should have kicked James/Sirius' behinds!!.

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Mon Jul 31 07:15:45 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 156220

"wynnleaf" <fairwynn at ...> wrote: 

> here we have the part eggplant must
> have missed because Sirius immediately
> hits Snape with a Petrificus Totalus 
> and Snape falls over again. 

You are quite right, I sand corrected. Nevertheless it doesn't seem to
me that Sirius's participation was decisive. I still believe that in a
one on one bare knuckles cage match between James and Snape James
would be the easy victor, at least when they were both 15. The fact
that James showed not the slightest hint of fear toward Snape
fortifies my theory I believe.

On the other hand it can not be denied that fighting ability is not
all there is to magic, or to life.

> I don't see *anywhere* in there where 
> James defeated Snape in any kind of 
> fair or even fight.

Any General will tell you that the last thing in the world they want
is a fair fight; they want all the advantages, every single one. They
will also tell you that you should never pick on someone bigger than
you, and should never kick an opponent UNLESS they are down. 

Eggplant









More information about the HPforGrownups archive