DD's Knowledge (was Re: Nice vs. Good, honesty,)
distaiyi
distaiyi at yahoo.com
Fri Jun 2 18:58:33 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153287
RE The Scar Quill/Punishment...
DD didn't generally interfere in the affairs of punishment and
whatnot, otherwise, every time Snape unfairly punished students he
would have been on it. He might not agree, but he seemed to let them
do as they will within the confines of rules he had set out.
Given other activities ongoing I'd suspect that his attention does wax
and wane given a) whether or not he's present and b) what else is
going on in his life at any given moement.
However, I'm not one to buy into DD's omniscience regarding Hogwarts.
As I said in another post. Only VOLDEMORT and HARRY found the CoS...
Dumbledore didn't.... TWICE.
Distaiyi -- Dumbledore Lives!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive