My Theory On The Prophecy

[Victoria Scott]

No: HPFGUIDX 153330

Clare:
<snip>
>I don't believe that there is room in the story for LV to be Harry's
>Horcrux.  It isn't worked for in the texts and JKR does work for her  
>revelations,
>they are set up.  It is an idea which could be explored in  fanfic if you 
>could
>find a way to make it work, I can't see a way myself.
>
>

G.C. writes:
I agree that there is really no room for LV to be Harry's horcrux, and it 
also wouldn't make any sense. This is because we know that you have to have 
killed to make a horcrux, and Harry so far hasn't done that, especially not 
when he was 1 year old.

I also think it is weird that LV didn't die when his AK backfired on him, we 
know that it's because he has gone to many lengths to become immortal, but 
it's really frustrating thrying to think about what happened. Is it because 
his body had his original soul and therefore this heart, mind etc so that 
part could not be destroyed by an AK, but the rest of his horcrux's could? 
Does that make sense? What i'm trying to say is that Harry may have to go to 
greater length to destroy the body form of Voldemort than it is to destroy 
the oher horcrux's. This is because the soul in the body, that was hit with 
the AK was carrying his mind and heart and the rest.

G.C Signing off