If it is not Voldemort, then who? - Is Dumbledore worried about someone else?

Hagrid aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Mon Jun 5 00:37:39 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 153373

---  "David" <foodiedb...> wrote:
>
> Hi all,
> 
>      I was just rereading part of GOF when I came across something 
> that I think might be noteworthy.  On page 601 of the US edition, 
> Harry is telling Dumbledore about the dream he had with Voldemort  
> in it.  After Harry finishes telling him about the dream, they 
> talk about how Voldemort could have held a wand (if he was 
> supposed to be so weak). Harry says:
> 
> "...how could he have held the wand?"
> 
> Dumbledore says:
> 
> "How indeed?" 
> 
> Then Dumbledore uses the Pensieve, then it reads:
> 
> "Professor," Harry said at last, "do you think he's getting 
> stronger?"
> 
> Now, to me, here is the curious part.  After Harry asks the above 
> question, Dumledore begins his reply by saying, 
> 
> "Voldemort?"  
> 
> Voldemort with a question mark?!
> 
> He then continues to say, "Once again, Harry, I can only give you 
> my suspicions."  
> 
> Well, speaking of suspicious, I find it suspicious that Dumbledore 
> had to clarify who Harry was talking about.  Who else did he think 
> Harry might be talking about?  Is there someone else out there 
> that Dumbledore is worried about becoming stronger?
> 
> I realize the Dumbledore was just using the Pensieve, but I still 
> think it is strange that he had to clarify who Harry was speaking 
> about.
> 
> Have a nice day,
> David, who loves treacle tart!
>
aussie:

I haven't put it all together, but I've been wondering if the Dark 
Wizard Grindelwald (famous from the back of Dumbledore's Choc Frog 
Card).

- If LV is used in a similar way Quirrel was used to piggy back the 
defeated Voldy ... 
- Could Tom have been used to be a "Horcrux" for Grindlewald
- and (this is stretching it now) ... Did LV want Draco to tear his 
soul to be a "Horcrux" for the next generation?

OK, organist, you can stop playing that eiry music in the background 
now








More information about the HPforGrownups archive