If it is not Voldemort, then who? - Is Dumbledore worried about someone else

xuxunette chonpschonps at hotmail.com
Tue Jun 6 04:39:00 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 153432

> Peggy: I take Dumbledore's comment as his having been called
> out of deep thought and back to the present moment by Harry's
> question. <snip>

> David says:
> I thought about Dumbledore just being deep in thought, but for
> some reason, I don't think that's it, I think that JKR wrote it
> that way for a reason. It could be just conincidence, but is
> there such a thing as "just a coincidence" in a JKR story.

xuxu:
I think it's most probably just a figure of speech. A rhetorical
question JKR used to avoid reader getting lost in the dialogue.

As far as the dialogue goes, it is fitting for Harry, jumping out
of the pensieve, to ask a spontaneous question, imprecise in its
formulating. But if the verbal exchange had continued without
Voldemort being named, it would have lacked clarity.

xuxu










More information about the HPforGrownups archive