Regulus and Kreacher

[JULIA WILKES]

No: HPFGUIDX 153471



Kayla <kayla_pittillo at ...> wrote:
> If Regulus was alive, wouldn't that mean Kreacher would have 
> automatically gone to him as being a Black, instead of Harry? 
> I seem to recall Kreacher was bound, although unwillingly, to
> Harry and not another Black. 

bboyminn:
> If the binding factor is Elfin Honor as I suspect, then Kreacher 
> would have had no way of knowing who was or wasn't alive, he would 
> simply have to follow his honor and go where he seemed to belong 
> regardless of his personal desires.

Julia:
Even if Regulus is still alive, Kreacher would still go to Sirius
because It Kreacher goes to the eldest surviving Black family member
and that is Sirius... Right?