Werewolf Mystery
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 14 01:57:15 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153809
> PAR: OR, Snape wasn't in danger from LUPIN. I haven't seen
anywhere
> in cannon that it is stated that Lupin was the real threat. It's
> clear that Snape thinks so, but what if there were a SECOND
werewolf
> (like greyback) there that night? <SNIP> My guess is that the
threat to Snape AND the
> one to James' life were NOT from Lupin. It's quite true that
Lupin
> might have bitten Snape (making him a werewolf) and that Snape saw
> Lupin as a werewolf. And this works with DD's statement that "my
> memory is as good as ever." when Snape brings up that Sirius
tried to
> kill him. --- because if the "prank" wasn't intended to kill but
it
> simply turned OUT to be a life-threatening incident, it puts a
whole
> different spin on James, Lupin and Sirius. And it makes one
wonder if
> the betrayal of the Potters was Peter's FIRST betrayal or if in
fact,
> there had been something "not quite right" during Peter's school
days.
Alla:
Oh, my goodness, PAR. I certainly saw many scenarious of what
ocurred that night and certainly suggested some, since I am one of
those who thinks that that night has many, many mysteries, but I
have not seen the presence of second werewolf suggested yet.
Veeeeery interesting. Do you mind speculating why Greyback could be
there? I mean, it is not that far fetched, I suppose since we know
that he bitten Remus, so maybe they had some kind of the connection?
Hmmm, certainly as good as any speculation.
As to Peter, well, absolutely. Among many questions that I have
about that night is where James and Peter were when the events in
question occurred. Weren't they supposed to be with Remus when he
transformed?
Why that night was different?
Did Peter choose not to go? What made James to not be there yet?
Alla.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive