Interesting email I received.... - Theory about Dumbledore not being dead

[Tonks]

No: HPFGUIDX 153955

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "zandi1717" <glzie17 at ...> wrote:
>
> I received this email this morning...
> 
> I AM NOT the author of this theory - but, feel compelled to post
> it.  I would love to see what the minds of this list think of this
> one..
> 
>> As Clear as Water
> An original editorial by Erez R.
> 

Tonks:
This idea has been around here before. Someone here said that LV 
would not make a whole lake into a potion. I think they are right.

I applaud and encourage any and all attempts to see beyond the 
obvious in the books. But I don't buy this one. DD is dead.  He might 
come back. But for that to happen he must, in fact, really, truly, be 
dead.

There is however, a chance that the D of LD will be used in the last 
book. I can see that happening somehow.  Maybe by Snape, or Slughorn 
or Hermione or even Harry since he got it right in class with the 
help of the HBP.

But DD is dead.

Tonks_op