Interesting email I received.... - Theory about Dumbledore not being

[canyoutellmehowtoget]

No: HPFGUIDX 153975

> zanooda:
>
> As for the e-mail you received I think
> that it would be more logical to put The Draught of Living Death into
> the basin, not into the lake. More direct approach, don't you think?
>


Joe:
More direct? You bet, but when has that dictated what JKR does.
Everyone expects that the green glowing liquid is the bad stuff, it
would be the old switcheroo to have the water (or what appears to be
water) be the more dangerous or potent of the two. Personally I was
grossed out to think that he would drink water that dead bodies were
floating in. Given the choice I might have gone for the green glowing
stuff. Might have been one of the new Gatorade flavors who knows. ;-)