Harry's arrogance /Evil Snape

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 154327

Alla:
> 
> I would even buy that DD was dying on the Tower IF DD did not ask 
> Snape to do him in.
> 
> Snape may have had the best intentions in mind, but one way or 
> another IMO it will be shown that he was wrong to take the life 
> instead of trying to save it.


Pippin:
My theory is that Snape did not take Dumbledore's life, he 
didn't try to defend it, and used a ruse to make it seem that he
had taken it. Are you saying that's far-fetched when we know
that there have been fake deaths in canon? 

Or are you saying that it  would be wrong? If so,  was it wrong for 
Lily to leave James  to his fate and try to flee with Harry? I don't think 
JKR is going there.

Pippin