Mortality of horcruxes?

[Monica Boukhalfa]

No: HPFGUIDX 154331

On Sun, 25 Jun 2006 8:04pm, sugaranddixie1 wrote:
> ET here-
>
> Been reading the "Of essence divided?" thread with great interest &
> it reminded me of something-
>
> I'm perplexed about the whole idea of having a living thing (such as
> a snake) or something like a scar as a horcrux.
>
> Why would you put a portion of your soul into something that has a
> definite lifespan?
Snip (sorry)

Monica now:
But what if Voldemort performed the horcrux spell FOR Nagini after she 
killed someone? (She almost took out Arthur, who's saying she hasn't 
actually killed someone at one point) and SHE has a horcrux. That would 
make the whole living thing horcrux make a lot more sense.

-Monica
<stiring the pot>
--Monica M. Boukhalfa