Harry's arrogance /Evil Snape

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 154345

> Carol notes:
> Or, assuming that DD really is dead, was it wrong to kill dumbledore
> if that was the only way to get Harry off the tower? 

Pippin:

I agree Snape could not have expected to get Harry and Draco off the
tower in one piece by fighting. Harry nearly got his throat ripped out
by one DE and was crucio'd by another. Snape was able to save him
from the latter only because the DE's were still taking his orders.

But assuming that DDM!Snape thought he could do a convincing fake 
AK, wouldn't he use that rather than a real one regardless?

Pippin
noting that if Dumbledore hadn't trusted Snape, he'd have died of the
Ring curse, and if Harry hadn't trusted the Prince, he'd have lost Ron.