[HPforGrownups] Re: Happy Birthday list Theory

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 154495

"Phil Vlasak"  wrote:
> >
> > Here is my collected list of birthday wishes from Jo's site:
> > ... List Snipped ...
>
>
> Tonks responded:
> OK If the Birthdays List Prediction Theory is correct (and we don't
> know if it is) … Tonks is not on it. This could be because she is
> not considered a major character. Lupin is there. All the Weasleys
> are there. Harry, Ginny, Neville and Hermione are there. All of the
> teachers are there.
>
> Others Not on it are:
> DD - I think because there is something about his birthday we are
> not suppose to know. Course he is also dead, so it could be the
> Theory at work.
>
> Luna
> Dudley
> Petunia
> Vernon
> Mad-eye Moody
> Flitch - isn't he a major character?
> ?????
>
> Well I started this, but I don't know... who are the major players
> here are who aren't? I mean is someone not on the list because they
> are going to die or because they are not important?
>
> And isn't it interesting that none of the bad guys are on it? Only
> Draco from the Malfoy family is there. Wonder if this means that he
> does have a change of allegiance in the last book. And if my "good
> guy list theory" is correct this is proof of Snape as DDM.
>
> 


Kemper now:

I notice Fluer isn't on the list, and she's had more page time, it seems,
than either Bill or Charlie.
Neither is Figgy.  I pray she lives.  I know her page time is insignificant,
but her role isn't.
Seamus and Dean, though maybe their Red Shirts who've lived a long time.
Trewlany.  Her page time is relatively significant as is her role.
Grawp.  Pretty please, JKR, slay him.  And slay him early.


-Kemper


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]