Trelawney

[Michelle]

No: HPFGUIDX 149032

Kchuplis wrote in
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/147854 :
> << The last time through OoTP and HBP I got the distinct impression
> that Trelawney's mutterings in the hallway while shuffling cards 
> etc. may show more "sight" than previously believed. >>

Catlady responded: 
> Yes! << snip quote >>
> 
> "A dark young man, possibly troubled, one who dislikes the 
> questioner" might or might not have anything to do with the knave 
> of spades, but it is Trelawney picking up Harry's presence 
> near. "The questioner" is herself, and Harry is troubled and does 
> dislike her. "Well, that can't be right" is because she refuses to 
> believe that anyone could dislike her.


michelle says:

I also believe this scene has more to it than what meets the "eye;" 
however I disagree with the "dark young man being Harry".  I think 
she is talking about Snape and the "questioner" he dislikes is LV.  
LV is always trying to get into Snape's head with Occlumancy, that's 
enough to dislike any questioner, whether or not Snape is ESE! or DDM!

michelle-who has been on hiatus due to an audit but is hopefully 
going to be able to catch up on posts now