Trusting Snape

[PJ]

No: HPFGUIDX 149052

Carol

> Carol, hoping that PJ will at least *understand* the DDM!Snape
> position now even if he or she doesn't agree with it

PJ:

Sorry, no.  

Trust me, it would be much *easier* to side with DDM!Snape since the 
non-DDM! folks are so badly outnumbered and you can't turn on the 
computer without tripping over 20 Ain't Snape Wonderful posts an hour, 
but I can't pretend to understand something that makes absolutely no 
sense to me.  

I've tried to see it from your(group you)point of view but all these 
intricate twists and turns ie: It wasn't a *real* AK that killed 
Dumbledore (huh??)or it was the *curse* rather than stupidity and 
hubris that made him take the UV, or even a smoldering passion for 
Cissy that just did the big guy in <sigh>.  All this to show him in a 
much better light than anything that's *actually written* on the pages 
by the author! I'm too old to start twisting myself into that kind of 
a pretzel.

I sincerely believe all his loyalty is reserved for himself and that  
you're all trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.  The 
embroidery, while pretty, still can't quite cover up the smell of pig.

I have bought a crow and a cookbook just in case I'm wrong.  We'll 
know in about a year if I need to defrost it.  :-) 

PJ (who is a she <grin>)