Moody WAS:Leader of Order of the Pheonix -Harry, Moody, Arthur, other

Ralph Miller papa at marvels.org
Fri Mar 3 21:26:58 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149065

bboyminn: 
... I don't think Harry is in a position to be the official leader of the
Order. ... While it could be Arthur, for the moment I am going to vote for
Mad-Eye Moody.
 
Geoff:
I hope that the suggestion in the last sentence will prove to be the final
"truth". ... Personally, I would not favour seeing Moody as the head of
the OOTP, not because I do not trust his loyalty but because I do not trust
his paranoia.
 
bboyminn:
I do agree about Moody's paranoia being his biggest draw back, but he is
still the most senior member, and the most skilled, experienced, and effective
Dark Wizard fighter. 

Ralph:
Excuse me for being dense, and I don?t have the books handy, but does canon
say that Moody really is paranoid? It?s suggested by characters, but not
borne out by his actions. Remember we have to ignore all actions by the
fake Moody. It seems to me that he thought he might be attacked by DEs so
he took precautions by drinking from a flask etc. Seems to me, considering
what  did happen, that wasn?t paranoia, but foresight.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive