Whose side is Snape on, anyway?

Kristin Hessenauer tropicwhale at yahoo.com
Fri Mar 3 23:32:45 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149088

unlikely2:

>> <snip> Can I suggest another reason why I think that Snape is good?

When Harry nearly kills Draco, Snape saves him and it is the intimate 
manner of his doing so that I find interesting. Singing. Not a potion 
but something from and of himself. And it is the cure for his own 
damaging spell. It is this act that the sorrowful song of the phoenix 
brings to my mind. <snip> <<

   
  I've never considered that as an option, it is interesting, and 
singing is how Fawkes healed so why not Snape as well. In Celtic and 
other mythologies "chants" are used to dregged up power and 'stop' 
death. Although, one must consider why Snape created the "Sectumsempra" 
spell to begin with..."use on enemies" the note said so who was the 
spell meant for?
   
  _Tropic_

		






More information about the HPforGrownups archive