Snape Survey

[puduhepa98 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 149116

> Luckdragon:
> Everytime I read my HP for Grownups email I see  pages and pages of 
> Snape. I don't think we will see the end of the "Is  Snape ESE or ESG 
> or OFH" until book seven is released; so, just for the  sake of being 
> able to tell each other "I told you so", let's tally up  what we 
> believe Snape is before we actually know, and see which way the  
> majority of us are thinking. A brief paragraph is sufficient.

I hope I am doing this right.  I felt I had to post my  opinion because it 
would be interesting to see the results if more than the  regular posters 
respond.  (I guess I am a lurker?) I vote for ESG for  several reasons.  If he is 
ESE or OFH, he is strangely ineffective for a  powerful and knowledgable wizard. 
 I also doubt that DD, who has  known him since he was 11 years old, could be 
fooled so completely.  For  plot development, the deliberate ambiguity JKR 
uses with Snape, would have no  purpose if he were bad.  Snape is Bad!  Would 
that be a  shock?.  Snape is Good really has a bite to it.
 
Nikkalmati