a bit of SHIP Ron/Hermione/Hermione must be stopped

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 8 05:05:54 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149250

Katssirius wrote:
<SNIP>
>> I was shocked by the 
> > level of ends justifying the means that Hermione was willing to 
> > engage including confunding McLaggen and attacking Ron with 
birds 
> > when he kissed Lavender.  

Hickengruendler:
<SNIP>
> I agree. But quite frankly, she was not the only one I disliked 
> during the middle of HBP. I hate all those chapters involving 
> Quidditch or shipping in HBP, because I found all the protagonists 
> awfully unsympathetic. Harry, Ron, Hermione and Ginny seemed to 
have 
> become their own close knitted group, who did not seem to care 
much 
> about the feelings of anyone outside. Which is annoying, because I 
> cannot remember them being that way (at least to that extreme, in 
the 
> earlier books). It still was Ginny, who I disliked the most, 
because 
> I have the impression that it is not Hermione, but *her*, who gets 
> applauded by the author no matter what she does.


Alla:

Oh, I don't know Hickengruendler,  to me Hermione was by far the 
least likable member of the Trio in HBP, but after all I freely 
admit that she IS my least favorite member of the Trio, period.  In 
fact, I think sometimes that I only like her because these three do 
so well together, as three friends. And it is not like she has some 
huge character flaws, she is a good loyal person, it is just her 
bossiness puts me off SO much.

And I think her attacking Ron with birds was appaling too. It is 
funny, I think JKR commented that Ron had to make himself worthy of 
Hermione in HBP. Personally, I happen to think that Hermione was not 
doing worthy things at all in that book. Ron did not make her any 
promises, they are just sixteen and going and assaulting him because 
she was jealous, IMO , well it was not nice at all.

JMO,

Alla







More information about the HPforGrownups archive